If you’re hunting for pizza in Myrtle Beach, you’ve got a ton of options—classic slices, creative toppings, and every vibe from family-friendly to quirky. Locals and visitors both seem to have their go-to spots, but honestly, sometimes you just want a little help narrowing it down.
1) AJ’S Pizza Myrtle Beach
AJ’S Pizza Myrtle Beach is a laid-back spot where you can grab anything from a classic cheese pizza to something a little more out there. They also do baked subs, pasta, and wraps, so you’re not stuck if someone in your group isn’t feeling pizza. The vibe is relaxed—good for families, big groups, or just grabbing a quick bite.
Pizzas are made with fresh stuff and you get a bunch of choices for toppings, both traditional and a bit more creative. Takeout and delivery are both available, which is a lifesaver if you’re just not up for eating out.
People rave about the friendly staff and fast service. AJ’s has a solid rep for keeping things tasty and consistent, and it shows in their reviews.
Location: 5917 N Kings Hwy, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577
2) Vicini’s Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria
Vicini’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria feels a bit cozier, with a homey atmosphere and a menu that covers more than just pizza—think pasta, house-baked bread, and even seafood. There’s outdoor seating if you want to eat al fresco, which is nice when the weather’s good.
They’ve got a wine bar and espresso bar, so whether you’re in the mood for a glass of red or just a shot of caffeine, you’re covered. Takeout is easy, and the staff makes you feel welcome whether you’re there for a quick dinner or a longer meal with friends.
Location: 5001 N Kings Hwy #105, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577
3) Mellow Mushroom Myrtle Beach
Mellow Mushroom is where you go if you want something different. Their stone-baked pizzas are loaded with fresh toppings, and they don’t shy away from unique combos. Gluten-free and vegan folks aren’t left out here, which is a relief.
The place is colorful and artsy, with a laid-back crowd. They’ve got 42 draft beers—yes, really—and some fun cocktails. You can hang out on the patio or just get delivery if you’re feeling lazy.
Catering is available if you’re feeding a crowd, and happy hour runs Monday through Thursday evenings. It’s open every day, with longer hours on weekends.
Location: 1571 21st Ave N, Myrtle Beach, SC
4) Little Italy
Little Italy does New York-style pizza—hand-tossed, thin, and just the right amount of crispy from their brick oven. The dough and sauce are made from scratch every day, which you can actually taste.
It’s not just pizza here. You’ll find scratch-made classics like manicotti, lasagna, and fresh-baked bread with every meal. There’s a real family-owned feel and the staff is super welcoming. Takeout and delivery are available within five miles, which is pretty generous.
Desserts like tiramisu, cannoli, and chocolate cake are worth saving room for. Happy hour runs Tuesday to Friday, 4–7 pm at the bar.
Location: 3001 N Kings Hwy, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577
5) Cafe Vincenzo’s
Cafe Vincenzo’s really leans into the authentic Italian thing, especially with their pizzas and classic pasta dishes. The spaghetti with house-made tomato sauce is a favorite, and you can tell they care about using fresh ingredients.
There are two floors: downstairs is casual and fast, while upstairs gets more lively, with dancing and a broader menu. It’s kind of a choose-your-own-adventure, depending on your mood.
They mix in some Mediterranean flavors too, like grilled salmon. Happy hour and catering are both available, so you can use the place for anything from birthdays to business events.
If you’re a regular, their rewards program is actually decent—freebies and quicker service if you order online. Not a bad perk for pizza fans.
Location: 7710 N Kings Hwy, Myrtle Beach, SC 29572
6) Capriccio
Capriccio keeps things simple: classic Italian comfort food, nothing too fancy. Their pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches use fresh ingredients, and the menu doesn’t try to reinvent the wheel.
The vibe is easygoing and family-friendly. Pizza here is straight-up traditional—no weird surprises, just solid flavors like you’d expect from a neighborhood spot.
Service is friendly, and the prices are reasonable. It’s usually busy, which says a lot about how consistent they are.
Location: 1285 38th Ave N, Myrtle Beach, SC
7) Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizzeria
Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizzeria is a great pick if you want more than just pizza. Besides the usual pies, they’ve got pasta dishes like baked penne, chicken fettuccine Alfredo, and eggplant parm. You can order these in different sizes, so it works for a quick lunch or a big group.
There’s a nice selection of salads—garden, antipasto, grilled chicken—and a few tasty starters like focaccia breadsticks and fried ravioli. Since it’s also a bakery, you get fresh Italian bread with your meal, which is a huge plus.
If you want something off-menu, just ask—they’re pretty flexible with custom orders.
Location: 550 Farrow Pkwy, Myrtle Beach, SC
8) Scotto’s Pizzeria
Scotto’s Pizzeria does classic Italian fare, focusing on fresh, local ingredients and old-school recipes. The pizza, especially the Sicilian, gets a lot of love for its authenticity—some folks even say it’s just like what you’d find in New Jersey.
The staff is friendly, and the place is clean and welcoming. The menu’s got plenty of variety, from Italian subs to daily specials. Ordering online gets you some discounts, and they encourage it for better service.
Locals and tourists both seem to keep coming back, mostly for the consistent quality and fair prices.
Location: 4030 River Oaks Dr, Myrtle Beach, SC 29579
9) Dough Boys NY Style Pizzeria
\
Dough Boys NY Style Pizzeria is all about that classic, straightforward New York-style pizza—hand-tossed dough, familiar flavors, no fancy frills. Besides pizza, you’ll find calzones, strombolis, pasta, and subs on the menu. It’s the kind of place you go when you just want good, reliable pizza without a fuss.
The atmosphere is super casual, and folks seem to appreciate the fresh ingredients and that the taste is always consistent. It’s a solid pick for dine-in or grabbing a pizza to go, depending on your mood.
You’ll find Dough Boys over on Beaver Run Boulevard in Myrtle Beach. It’s got a loyal local crowd, especially among people craving a real New York slice without leaving town.
Location: 2696 Beaver Run Blvd, Myrtle Beach, SC 29575
10) Extreme Pizza Myrtle Beach
Extreme Pizza Myrtle Beach leans into creative, bold pizza toppings. You’ll see everything from classic to wheat, vegan gluten-free, and even cauliflower crusts. Pizzas come in all sizes, so whether you’re solo or feeding a crew, you’re covered.
The menu isn’t just about pizza. There are wings, fries, fried pickles, mozzarella sticks, and a bunch of fresh salads with different dressings. You can dine in, order takeout, get delivery, or even pick up a take-and-bake pizza.
Some of their pies are loaded with meat—like The Mammoth and The Spice Route—while others cater to vegetarians, such as The Bunny Slope and The Veggin’ Spice Route. Or you can just build your own, mixing and matching sauces, cheeses, meats, veggies, and even fruits or nuts if you’re feeling adventurous.
If you’re not in the mood for pizza, Extreme Pizza has subs that come with fries or chips. Some are classic, while others go for more creative flavors, like The Buffalo Grind and The Natural.
Location: 1310 Celebrity Cir, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577
Essential Pizza Styles in Myrtle Beach
Myrtle Beach has a pretty wide range of pizza styles. Some places do thin, foldable slices, while others serve thick, hearty pies. There’s something for just about every pizza mood.
New York-Style Pizza
If you like your pizza big, thin, and easy to fold, New York-style is the way to go. The crust gets crispy on the edge but stays soft in the middle, so you can fold it without it snapping. Usually, it’s topped with a simple tomato sauce, mozzarella, and just a few toppings.
A lot of Myrtle Beach pizzerias really nail this style, focusing on good dough and fresh toppings. It’s a go-to for a quick meal or sharing with friends—honestly, it’s tough to go wrong here.
Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian pizza is the thick, square kind with a dough that’s almost bread-like and full of air bubbles. Even though it’s thick, it feels light inside, and the crust gets a little crispy. The sauce is usually rich and tangy, and you get a generous amount.
Toppings tend to be simple but bold—think strong cheeses and herbs. If you’re hungry and want something filling with a nice contrast between soft and crispy, this style hits the spot.
Thin Crust Versus Deep Dish
Thin crust pizza is everywhere in Myrtle Beach, and people love it for the crunch and lighter feel. It cooks up fast and usually comes in bigger slices, letting the toppings shine since the crust isn’t too heavy.
Deep dish is another story—it’s got a thick, sturdy crust that holds a ton of sauce and cheese. It’s a heavier meal and takes longer to bake, but it’s super satisfying if you’re really hungry.
Choosing between the two? It comes down to how hungry you are and what kind of texture you’re after. Most local spots have both, so you can switch it up.
Tips for Enjoying Pizza in Myrtle Beach
Want to really enjoy pizza here? It helps to think about what to drink with your meal and when to go. The right drink can make the flavors pop, and timing your visit can save you from long waits.
Pairing Pizza with Local Beverages
There are plenty of local drink choices in Myrtle Beach that go great with pizza. Craft beers from local breweries are always a hit—a light lager or pale ale balances out tomato sauce and cheese nicely.
Not into alcohol? Sweet tea is a classic around here. It’s sweet enough to cut through spicy toppings but not so strong it takes over the pizza.
If you’re a wine fan, a lighter red like Pinot Noir works well with both meat and veggie pizzas. And, hey, picking a local wine when you can is a nice way to support nearby vineyards.
Best Times to Dine Out
Pizza spots in Myrtle Beach can get packed, especially on weekends and during tourist season. Weekday afternoons are usually quieter, so you’ll get faster service and a more laid-back vibe.
If you go right before or after the dinner rush—say, around 4 or 5 PM, or after 8 PM—you’ll probably avoid the crowds. Some places even have lunch specials, so early afternoon could save you a few bucks.
It’s worth checking if your chosen place takes reservations, especially if you’re with a group or hitting a popular spot. That way, you’re not stuck waiting around.
Frequently Asked Questions
There are quite a few pizza places in Myrtle Beach, each with their own style and vibe. Some focus on classic New York slices, others go for brick oven flavor, and lots of top spots offer delivery, so you’ve got options.
Where can I find authentic New York style pizza in Myrtle Beach?
Gino’s Real New York Pizza is a favorite for true New York-style slices. Expect thin crust and the kind of toppings you’d see in NYC.
What are the top 10 pizza places in Myrtle Beach?
Some favorites are AJ’s Pizza Myrtle Beach, Vicini’s Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria, Mellow Mushroom Myrtle Beach, Little Italy, and Cafe Vincenzo’s. They all get good reviews for quality and variety.
Which pizza restaurants in Myrtle Beach offer delivery services?
AJ’s Pizza Myrtle Beach is known for delivery, and Little Italy often delivers too, depending on where you are and what day it is.
Are there any pizza places in North Myrtle Beach that are highly rated?
Definitely. Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria is one that gets a lot of love for its quality and flavor.
What is the best brick oven pizza restaurant in Myrtle Beach?
Crave Italian Oven & Bar stands out for its wood-fired, brick oven pizzas. If you’re after that style, it’s a strong pick.
Which pizza place in Myrtle Beach has been voted as the best by locals?
AJ’s Pizza Myrtle Beach often gets the top spot with locals. People seem to love their fresh ingredients and the wide range of toppings. If you’re in town and craving pizza, it’s probably worth checking out.
